The underlying logic of laser performance differences and market choices
Posted by： Hangao Time：2025-3-7 9:32:56
Laser technology is the "high-precision scalpel" of modern industry. The performance of its core device, the laser, directly determines the processing efficiency, product quality and long-term economy. However, with the explosive growth of market demand, the quality of lasers has become polarized: high-end equipment is based on the core competitiveness of ** beam quality, thermal attenuation control, and life stability**, while low-end products reduce costs by sacrificing key parameters, causing users to fall into the decision-making dilemma of "short-term low price" and "long-term loss".
From the technical principle, the essence of the laser is to achieve efficient conversion of light energy through stimulated radiation, and this process is restricted by multiple factors such as ** gain medium purity, heat dissipation design, and pump source stability**. For example, high-quality fiber lasers use single-mode optical fibers doped with rare earth elements, and the beam quality (M2 value) can be as low as 1.1. The energy concentration is more than 3 times that of inferior products. When welding stainless steel, the heat-affected zone can be reduced to less than 0.1mm, significantly reducing the deformation of the workpiece. However, due to material impurities and process defects, inferior lasers are often accompanied by problems such as beam divergence and power fluctuations, and even cause fatal defects such as weld porosity and cracks.
What is more noteworthy is that the **thermal attenuation characteristics** of the laser are directly related to its lifespan. High-quality equipment controls the temperature of core components below 35°C through a composite heat dissipation system (such as water cooling + air cooling redundant design), the power attenuation rate can be less than 0.5%/thousand hours, and the continuous working life can reach more than 30,000 hours; while inferior products have insufficient heat dissipation, and the power attenuation of more than 10% occurs after only 500 hours of operation in a high temperature environment, and the aging rate of the device increases exponentially. This difference will lead to a surge in maintenance costs in long-term use, and even loss of production capacity due to frequent downtime.
Therefore, understanding the performance watershed of lasers is not only a deepening of technical cognition, but also a rational choice of return on investment. The following will analyze the essential differences between good and bad lasers from the three dimensions of **beam quality, thermal management, and life verification**, and reveal the economic accounts behind them based on industry measured data.
1. Core advantages of high-quality lasers
1. Beam quality and stability
? High beam quality (M2 <1.3): High-quality lasers (such as IPG fiber lasers) use single-mode optical fibers, with spot diameters as precise as 0.03mm and weld depth-to-width ratios of 10:1, suitable for welding 0.1mm thin plates and 20mm thick plates.
? Power stability: Output power fluctuations <±1% to avoid inconsistent welding penetration (inferior lasers can fluctuate up to ±5%, resulting in weld porosity >5%).
2. Thermal attenuation control and lifespan
? Heat dissipation design: Using a water-cooling + air-cooling composite system, the continuous operating temperature is ≤35°C, and the power attenuation rate is still maintained at <0.5%/thousand hours in a high temperature environment (such as a 50°C workshop).
? Service life: High-quality lasers (such as the IPG YLS series) have a service life of 30,000 hours at 70% of the rated power, while inferior products (without brand certification) have a service life of only 5,000-8,000 hours, and a fast light attenuation rate (annual average attenuation >5%).
3. Intelligence and compatibility
? Real-time monitoring: built-in penetration sensor and AI algorithm, automatically compensate for power fluctuations (such as penetration error <0.1mm when welding speed changes by ±10%).
? Modular design: supports multi-wavelength composite welding (such as optical fiber + semiconductor laser), suitable for stainless steel, aluminum alloy and other materials.
---
II. Typical defects of inferior lasers
1. Beam divergence and energy waste
? Low beam quality (M2 >3): The spot diameter exceeds 0.5mm, and the heat-affected zone expands by 50% when welding stainless steel, resulting in deformation ≥0.2mm/meter (high-quality products ≤0.05mm/meter).
? Wavelength drift: For every 10℃ increase in temperature, the wavelength of the inferior semiconductor laser shifts by >2nm, causing the material absorption rate to decrease (the absorption rate of stainless steel for 1μm wavelength drops from 60% to 40%).
2. Severe thermal attenuation and short lifespan
? Insufficient heat dissipation: Relying only on air cooling, the power attenuation is ≥10% after 1 hour of continuous operation, and frequent shutdowns are required for cooling (high-quality lasers can run continuously for 24 hours).
? Fast device aging: In the 75℃ accelerated aging test, the current increase of low-quality laser diodes in 1000 hours is >20%, while the increase of high-quality products is <5%.
3. High maintenance cost
? Failure rate: The average annual failure rate of low-quality lasers is ≥3 times (module damage, optical path deviation), and the maintenance cost accounts for more than 30% of the equipment price; the failure rate of high-quality products is <0.5 times/year, and remote diagnosis is supported.
? Poor compatibility: It cannot be adapted to mainstream welding heads (such as Scan heads and swing heads), and the cost of transformation is as high as tens of thousands of yuan.
---
III. Key indicators for selecting high-quality lasers
1. Certification standards: give priority to brands that meet ISO 11146 (beam quality) and IEC 60825 (safety level) certifications.
2. Cooling system: dual-circulation water cooling + redundant heat dissipation design (such as IPG's YLS-AMB system).
3. Measured data: Suppliers are required to provide third-party life test reports (such as 75℃/1000 hours aging data under Telcordia standards).
4. Service guarantee: Warranty period ≥ 3 years, providing value-added services such as penetration depth detection and process optimization.
---
Suggestion: If the budget allows, give priority to medium and high power models (≥6kW) of leading brands (such as IPG, Raycus Laser), and match them with regular thermal attenuation detection (monitor the power curve every quarter). For scenarios with limited budgets, standardized models of domestic second-tier brands (such as Chuangxin Laser) can be selected, but heat dissipation and process parameter monitoring need to be strengthened.
Guangdong Henkel Technology Co., Ltd.
Recommended reading: Electromagnetic control device
Recommended reading: Welding tracking system
Hotline: 189-4243-7326
